За 1946

EQMM Contest:
Manly Wade Wellman for "A Star for a Warrior" 4/46.

1947

EQMM Contest:
H. F. Heard "The President of the United States, Detective" 3/47.

1948

EQMM Contest:
Alfredo Segre for "Justice Has No Number" 4/48.

1949

EQMM Contest:
Жорж Сименон "Маленький портной и шляпник" - Georges Simenon for "Blessed Are the Meek" (Le Petit Tailleur et le Chapelier) 4/49.

1950

EQMM Contest:
Джон Диксон Карр «Джентльмен из Парижа» - John Dickson Carr "The Gentleman from Paris" 4/50.

1951

EQMM Contest:
Charlotte Armstrong "The Enemy" 5/51.

1952

EQMM Contest:
Thomas Flanagan "The Cold Winds of Adesta" 4/52.

1953

EQMM Contest:
Steve Frazee "My Brother Down There" 4/53.

1954

EQMM Contest:
Roy Vickers "Double Image" 4/54.

1955

EQMM Contest: Стэнли Эллин «Момент решения» - Stanley Ellin for "The Moment of Decision" 3/55.

1956

EQMM Contest:
A.H.Z. Carr WON for "The Black Kitten" 4/56.

1957

EQMM Contest:
Avram Davidson WON for "The Necessity of His Condition" 4/57.

1962

EQMM Contest:
Cornell Woolrich for "One Drop of Blood" 4/62.

1963

2nd: Пэт МакГерр "Справедливость не всем по карману" - "Justice Has a High Price" by Pat McGerr

1967

EQMM-CWA Contest:
Кристианна Бранд «Осиное гнездо» (Библиотечка) - Christianna Brand for "Twist for Twist" 5/67

1968

EQMM-MWA Contest:
Patricia McGerr for "Match Point in Berlin" 6/68.

EQMM-CWA Contest:
P.D. James for "Moment of Power" 7/68.

1970

EQMM-CWA Contest: H.R.F. Keating for "The Old Shell Collector" 7/70.

1985

1st : Кларк Ховард "Зверье" - Clark Howard, "Animals" Jun/1985
2nd : Lawrence Block, "Like a Bug on a Windshield" Oct/1985
3rd : Clark Howard, "McCulla's Kid" Sep/1985

1986

1st : Clark Howard, "Scalplock" Jul/1986
2nd : Thomas Adcock, "Thrown-Away Child" Oct/1986
3rd : Nell Lamburn, "Tom's Thatch" Jul/1986

1987

1st : Роберт Барнард "Женщина в шкафу" - Robert Barnard, "The Woman in the Wardrobe" Dec/1987
2nd : Ann Bayer, "A Pleasure to Deal With" Nov/1987
3rd : John F. Suter, "That Man's Moccasins Have Holes" Jul/1987

1988

1st : Clark Howard, "The Dakar Run" Aug/1988
2nd : Питер Ловси «Оса" - Peter Lovesey, "The Wasp" Nov/1988
3rd : Clark Howard, "The Color of Death" Jun/1988

1989

1st : James Powell, "A Dirge for Clowntown" Nov/1989
2nd : Doug Allyn, "Star Pupil" Oct/1989
3rd : Patricia Moyes, "The Faithful Cat" Dec/1989

1990

1st : Clark Howard, "Deeds of Valor" Nov/1990
2nd : Clark Howard, "Challenge the Widow-Maker" Aug/1990
3rd : Peter Massarelli, "Once Upon a Time" Dec/1990

1991

1st : Peter Lovesey, "The Crime of Miss Oyster Brown" May/1991
2nd : Clark Howard, "Dark Conception" Oct/1991
3rd : Peter Lovesey, "Supper with Miss Shivers" Mid-Dec/1991

1992

1st : Doug Allyn, "Candles in the Rain" Nov/1992
2nd : Jo Bannister, "Howler" Oct/1992
3rd : Doug Allyn, "Icewater Mansions" Jan/1992

1993

1st : Doug Allyn, "The Ghost Show" Dec/1993
2nd : Steven Saylor, "The House of the Vestals" Apr/1993
3rd : Peter Lovesey, "You May See a Strangler" Mid-Dec/1993

1994

1st : Jan Burke, "Unharmed" mid-Dec/1994
2nd : Doug Allyn, "Black Water" Oct/1994
3rd : Doug Allyn, "The Cross-Wolf" Mid-Dec/1994

1995

1st : Doug Allyn, (tied) "Franken Kat" mid-Dec/1995
1st : Джеффри Дивер “Рыбалка” - Jeffery Deaver, "Gone Fishing" Oct/1995
2nd : Brendan DuBois, "Heirlooms" Jul/1995
3rd : Edward D. Hoch, "The Killdeer Chronicles" Mid-Dec/1995

1996

1st : Doug Allyn, "Roadkill" May/1996
2nd : Doug Allyn, "Puppyland" Sep-Oct/1996
3rd : Steven Saylor, "The White Fawn" Dec/1996

1997

1st : Jeffery Deaver, "Double Jeopardy" Sep-Oct/1997
2nd : Doug Allyn, "Copperhead Run" Jun/1997
3rd : George C. Chesbro, "The Problem with the Pigs" Jun/1997

1998

1st : Kristine Kathryn Rusch, "Details" Dec/1998
2nd : Barbara D'Amato, "Of Course You Know That Chocolate Is a Vegetable" Nov/1998
3rd : Joan Richter, "Recipe Secrets" Sep-Oct/1998

1999

1st : Clark Howard, "The Global Man" Dec/1999
2nd : Michael A. Kahn, "The Bread of Affliction" Sep-Oct/1999
3rd : Minette Walters, " The Tinder Box" Dec/1999

2000

1st : Doug Allyn, "The Death Row Pet Show" Apr/2000
2nd : Doug Allyn, "The Christmas Mitzvah" Dec/2000
3rd : Donald Olson, "Don't Go Upstairs" Aug/2000

2001

1st : Peter Sellers, "Avenging Miriam" Dec/2001
2nd : David Handler, "The Mondo Whammy" Sep-Oct/2001
3rd : Neil Schofield, "Groundwork" Nov/2001

2002

1st : Jeffery Deaver, "Without Jonathan" Nov/2002
2nd : Эдвард Хоч «Невозможное происшествие с ястребом Бейли» - Edward D. Hoch, "The Problem of Bailey's Buzzard" Dec/2002
3rd : Doug Allyn, "Telephone to Forever" Jul/2002

2003

1st : Doug Allyn, "Palace in the Pines" Jul/2003
2nd : Clark Howard, "The Mask of Peter" Apr/2003
3rd : Clark Howard, "The Leper Colony" Aug/2003

2004

1st : Doug Allyn, "The Gin Mill" Sep-Oct/2004
2nd : Clark Howard, "Deep Lock" Dec/2004
3rd : Clark Howard, "Tequila Memories" Jun/2004

2005

1st : Doug Allyn, "Wolf Woman Bay" Jun/2005
2nd : J.A. Konrath, "With a Twist" Dec/2005
3rd : Robert S. Levinson, "Death Conquers All" Sep-Oct/2005

2006

1st : Leigh Lundin (writing under L. Leigh), "Swamped" Aug/2006
2nd : Doug Allyn, "The Black Chapel" Sep-Oct/2006
3rd : Edward D. Hoch, "A Convergence of Clerics" Dec/2006

2007

1st : David Dean, (tied) "Ibrahim's Eyes" Jun/2007
1st : Edward D. Hoch, "The Theft of the Ostracized Ostrich" Sep-Oct/2007
2nd : Dale C. Andrews and Kurt Sercu, "The Book Case" May/2007
3rd : Дуг Эллин «Сдохнуть как собака» - Doug Allyn, "Stone-Cold Christmas" Jan/2007

2008

1st : Kristine Kathryn Rusch, "The Secret Lives of Cats" Jul/2008
2nd : Doug Allyn, "The Sonnets of September" Jul/2008
3rd : Brendan DuBois, "The Blue Plate Special" Mar-Apr/2008

Номинанты:
4. Too Wise - O'Neil De Noux
5. Keller the Dogkiller - Lawrence Block
6. Who's Afraid of Nero Wolfe? - Loren D. Estleman
7. Manila Burning - Clark Howard
8. Body and Fender - James H. Cobb
9. The Moorhead House - Kristine Kathryn Rusch
10. A Scandal in Montreal - Edward D. Hoch

2009

1: Mike Herron's "Dolphin Junction" tied with Doug Allyn's "An Early Christmas"
2: Clark Howard's "White Wolves"
3: Dave Zeltserman's "Julius Katz"

Номинанты:
4: Doug Allyn's "Famous Last Words"
5: Doug Allyn's "The Valhall Verdict"
6: Jack Fredrickson's "For the Jingle"
7: Janvillem van de Wetering's "The Bleeding Chair"
8: Lee Goldberg's "The Case of the Piss-Poor Gold"
9: Lou Manfredo's "Central Islin, USA"
10: Brian Muir's "Dummy"

2010

1. Dave Zeltserman, “Archie’s Been Framed” (September/October)
2. Doug Allyn, “The Scent of Lilacs” (September/October)
3. Doug Allyn, “Days of Rage” (March/April)

Номинанты:
4.Ли Голдберг “Мистер Монк и семнадцать ступенек” - Lee Goldberg, “Mr. Monk and the Seventeen Steps” (December)
5. Brendan DuBois, “To Kill an Ump” (September/October)
6. Clark Howard, “Winter’s End” (December)
7. Clark Howard, “Last Dance in Shanghai” (June)
8. Evan Lewis, “Skyler Hobbs and the Rabbit Man” (February)
9. Stephen Ross, “The Man with One Eye” (December)
10. Carol Biederman, “The Changelings: A Very Grim Fairytale” (November)

2011

1. P. N. Elrod, "Beach Girl", Nov 2011

2012

1. "Wood-Smoke Boys" by Doug Allyn (Mar/Apr)
2. "Mariel" by David Dean (Dec)
3. "Champawat" by Lia Matera (Sept/Oct)

4. "Skyler Hobbs and the Garden Gnome Bandit" by Evan Lewis (Sept/Oct)
5. "Dial Country Code 91 + M for Murder" by Stewart Brown (Dec)
6. “Death of a Drama Queen,” by Doug Allyn (September/October)
7. “So Near Any Time Always,” by Joyce Carol Oates (March/April)
8. “Black Pearls,” by Clark Howard (May)
9. “One Angry Julius Katz and Eleven Befuddled Jurors,” by Dave Zeltserman (June)
10. “Golden Chance,” by S.J. Rozan (December)

2013

1. “Archie Solves the Case,” by Dave Zeltserman
2. “Borrowed Time,” by Doug Allyn
3. “The Wickedest Town in the West,” by Marilyn Todd

4. “Sob Sisters,” by Kris Nelscott
5. “Jack and the Devil,” by David Dean
6. “Cemetery Man,” by Bill Pronzini
7. “The Care and Feeding of Houseplants,” by Art Taylor
8. “In a Dark Manner,” by David Dean
9. “Darkness in the City of Light,” by Hilary Davidson
10. “Ghost Writer,” by Val McDermid

2014

1: "The Snow Angel," by Doug Allyn (January 2014)
2: "Blood Red Roses," by Marilyn Todd (September/October 2014)
3: "the Tavern Keeper's Daughter," by Miriam Grace Monfredo (December 2014)

2015

1: "We on the Train!" by Margaret Maron (May 2015)
2 (ties): "The Lake Tenant," by Brendan DuBois (November 2015)
and "No Cabs After Midnight," by William Halstead (June 2015)
3: "Rizzo's Good Cop," by Lou Manfredo (December 2015)

2016

1: "Ghosts of Bunker Hill," by Paul D. Marks (December 2016)
2: "Puncher's Chance," by Doug Allyn (June 2016)
3: "The Dropout," by Doug Allyn (March/April 2016)

2017

1: "Flowing Waters," by Brendan DuBois (printed in the January/February 2017 issue)
2: "Tombstone," by Doug Allyn (November/December 2017)
3: "Cramer in Trouble," by Dave Zeltserman (March/April 2017)

2018

1: Stacy Woodson for “Duty, Honor, Hammett” (11-12/18)
2: Josh Pachter for “50” (11-12/18)
3: David Dean for “Sofee” (3-4/18)

2019

1: "The Duelist," by David Dean (May/June 2019)
2 (tied): "Fade-Out on Bunker Hill," by Paul D. Marks (March/April 2019)
2: "The Dutchy," by Doug Allyn (November/December 2019)
3: "Whitehout," by G.M. Malliet (January/February 2019)

4: “Snow Boy" by David Dean
5: “The Girls in the Fourth Row" by Doug Allyn
6: " Heat" by Trey Dowell tied with "Better Days by Art Taylor
7: "Wishing Tree" by Michael Bracken tied with "Sac-a-lait Man" by O'Neil De Noux
8: “The Cripplegate Apprehension" by Richard Helms
9: “The Retirement Plan" by Stacy Woodson
10: “Fiction Addiction" by Christine Poulson

2020

1: Barb Goffman for "Dear Emily Etiquette" (September/October 2020)
2: John M. Floyd fro "Crow's Nest" (January/February 2020)
3: Gregory Fallis for "Terrible Ideas" (September/October 2020)

2021

1. Karen Harrington for “Boo Radley College Prep,” (January/February 2021 issue of EQMM).
2. “Demon in the Depths,” by Bill McCormick (September/October)
3. Tie — “Bad Chemistry,” by John Wimer (July/August)
3. Tie — “Black Swallowtail,” by Hollis Seamon (March/April)
4. Tie — “Kiss of Life,” by Doug Allyn (May/June)
4. Tie — “A Season of Night,” by David Dean (May/June)
4. Tie — “Julius Katz and the Two Cousins,” by Dave Zeltserman (July/August)
5. “No Legacy So Rich,” by Anna Scotti (January/February)
6. Tie — “Leap of Faith,” by Marilyn Todd (May/June)
6. Tie — “The Last Man in Lafarge,” by Joseph Walker (July/August)
7. “The Fraud of Dionysus,” by Smita Harish Jain (July/August)
8. “The Lemonade Stand,” by Scott Loring Sanders (January/February)
9. “Curious Incidents,” by Steve Hockensmith (January/February)
10. “The White Star,” by G.M. Malliet (July/August)